Two spot-the-difference pictures of a house and tree with the differences circled, titled Make Your Own Puzzle

Making a spot-the-difference puzzle is a great project for a rainy afternoon, a classroom activity, or a personalised birthday party game. It is also the best way to understand why good puzzles are hard to solve. This guide covers three methods: drawing by hand, editing a photo, and designing a puzzle for a specific age. It ends with the design rules we follow when we make levels for Diffora.

1 Method one: draw it by hand

You need paper, a pencil, a black pen, colouring pens or pencils, and access to a photocopier, scanner or a sunny window.

  1. Draw a simple scene in pencil. A street, a park, a kitchen, an underwater scene. Aim for ten to twenty distinct objects. Too few and there is nowhere to hide differences; too many and young players get lost.
  2. Go over the lines in pen. Clean outlines make copying easier.
  3. Make an identical copy. Photocopy or scan the line drawing twice. No copier? Tape the drawing to a window, put a fresh sheet on top, and trace it in daylight.
  4. Add your differences to one copy only. Erase a detail, add a small object, change a shape. Keep a list as you go. It is easy to forget one!
  5. Colour both pictures. Colour them the same, except for one or two deliberate colour differences. Do colour changes last so you don't accidentally create extras.
  6. Test it on someone. Watch where they struggle. If nobody finds a difference, it may be too small; if everyone finds them all in ten seconds, make the next one harder.

2 Method two: edit a photo

Photo puzzles feel more "real" and are often harder because of all the natural detail. Any phone or computer photo editor with a clone or "remove" tool will do.

  1. Choose a busy, well-lit photo. Market stalls, bookshelves, gardens and street scenes work well. Avoid blurry or very dark photos: differences in shadows are frustrating rather than fun.
  2. Duplicate the image so you always keep an untouched original.
  3. Remove objects with a remove or clone tool. A sign, a bird, a window, a stripe on an awning.
  4. Change colours by selecting one object and adjusting its hue. Change just that object, not the whole picture.
  5. Copy and move small objects, such as a flower, a cup or a leaf, to a slightly different place, or flip one horizontally.
  6. Zoom out and check. Every edit should look natural. A blurry smudge where an object used to be gives the game away immediately.
  7. Save both images at the same size and place them side by side, or one above the other on a phone.
Tip: photos of your own home, pets or family make wonderful personalised puzzles for birthdays and holidays. Children love finding differences in a picture of their own bedroom.

3 Choosing the right number of differences

  • Ages 3 to 5: three to five large, obvious changes, such as a missing object or a whole object in a new colour.
  • Ages 6 to 9: five to seven changes, mixing easy and medium.
  • Ages 10 and adults: seven to ten changes, including a couple of really subtle ones.

4 Types of difference to use

A good puzzle mixes several kinds of change, so players have to switch between different ways of looking:

  • Missing: something present in one picture is gone in the other.
  • Added: a new object appears.
  • Colour: the same object in a different colour.
  • Shape or size: a longer tail, a bigger window, a rounder hat.
  • Position or direction: an object moved, or an animal facing the other way.
  • Count: four buttons instead of three, one fewer stripe.
  • Pattern: spots turned into stripes, or a missing tile in a floor.

5 Design rules that make puzzles fair

When we build Diffora levels, a few rules help keep puzzles challenging without being annoying:

  • Spread differences around. Don't cluster them all in one corner. Players should be rewarded for checking the whole picture.
  • Make each difference clearly separate. If two changes touch, players may tap one and feel cheated when it only counts once.
  • A difference should be visible, not microscopic. A change of a few pixels on a phone screen isn't a puzzle, it's an eye test.
  • Avoid accidental differences. Uneven cropping, a slight shift of the whole image or a change in brightness will confuse players. Check that only your intended changes are different.
  • Include one or two "gimmes". An easy first find gets players started and builds confidence.
  • Keep an answer key. Circle the differences on a third copy so anyone stuck can check.

6 Using your puzzle

Homemade puzzles work brilliantly as party activities, classroom warm-ups, holiday cards or a surprise in a lunchbox. Turn it into a team challenge or a timed race. For more ideas, see our list of spot-the-difference games for families, and teachers might like our classroom guide.

And when you want a puzzle you didn't make yourself, there is always a fresh one waiting in Diffora's free online game.

Ready to put your eyes to the test?

Play Diffora
Download Diffora on the App Store Get Diffora on Google Play
Spot-the-difference tips Frequently asked questions Explore the worlds